Contents
Rethinking the Enrolment Journey Designing for continuity across planning, enrolment and timetabling systems. Zhuoer (Kaylee) Li INFO90009 User Experience Design Supervisor: Dr Arzoo Atiq University of Melbourne Faculty of Engineering and Information Technology School of Computing and Information Systems Submitted in partial fulfilment of the degree of Master of Information Technology (Human-Computer Interaction) November 2026
Abstract Every semester, University of Melbourne students move between the Handbook, My Course Planner, my.unimelb and MyTimetable to choose subjects, enrol and organise their timetables. This project looks at how students move between these stages and where the process breaks down. Interviews with 11 students and 38 valid questionnaire responses showed that students had to manually add planned subjects again, could not always tell Planned from Enrolled, discovered timetable clashes only after enrolling, and largely worked out the process on their own. Based on these findings, I designed a prototype that brings these stages together into one connected journey. Six students tested the first high-fidelity version through four tasks. Their feedback helped refine the final design.
The current fragmented journey Context University of Melbourne students choose subjects, formally enrol in them and organise their class times using different tools. The  is the University’s official subject catalogue, providing subject content, requirements and availability.  is an optional tool for mapping subjects across years and semesters. Formal enrolment takes place through the  in the  section of . Students then use  to view class times and organise their timetable. HandbookMy Course PlannerStudy PlanMy Studymy.unimelbMyTimetable Problem Problems mainly occur between these tools. Choices made in  do not sync to the , requiring students to search for and add the same subjects again. Although class times are available before enrolment through  links and ’s Plan function, many students are unaware of these options or do not use them. They may discover clashes or unsuitable times only after enrolling, leading them to revisit their subject choices. These difficulties are compounded by infrequent use and a recent update to the  enrolment interface, which can leave even experienced students working out the process again. My Course PlannerStudy PlanHandbookMyTimetablemy.unimelb
Literature Review I looked for research on the difficulties students experience when navigating university enrolment systems. These studies showed that related problems have been reported at different universities over more than a decade, and gave me a starting point for what to look for in my own fieldwork. Theme 1: Course selection is a decision-making process Choosing subjects is more than an administrative step. Students weigh their interests, career value, expected grades and peer advice, so the same subject may appeal to different students for different reasons (Ma et al., 2021). Cha et al. (2024) describe course selection as search, evaluation and final choice. During this process, students often looked beyond official descriptions and relied on peer information. Official information had its own problems, as some students felt course titles did not reflect the actual content, while others struggled with lengthy descriptions. Theme 2: Digital tools do not necessarily remove manual planning work Planning and enrolment tools often support one part of the task, but leave students to connect the rest by hand. Students using ASSIST, California’s official system for checking course transfers, could find equivalent courses but still had to visit college websites to check availability and prerequisites. For one participant, this manual checking took four to five hours (Nguyen et al., 2026). Similarly, students at NYU planned their timetables outside the Albert registration system, using personal calendars and manual notes (NYU Usability Lab, n.d.). The same pattern appeared at MacEwan University, where only three out of ten participants felt they could manage timetabling without pen and paper (Estevez et al., 2014). Theme 3: Registration systems must be easy to learn and return to Students only return to registration systems a few times a year, making learnability and memorability especially important (Estevez et al., 2014). At MacEwan University, four inexperienced participants added a course to the enrolment cart and believed they were registered (Estevez et al., 2014). This confusion shows how an unclear distinction between temporary and confirmed status can make the process difficult to understand. Unclear steps had a similar effect in Triyanti et al.’s (2025) usability evaluation, where some participants found adding courses complicated and repetitive, could not identify the next action and abandoned the task. Gap and Research Aim Each of these studies focuses on one part of the process. What I wanted to understand was what happens in between. In this project, I looked at the enrolment journey at the University of Melbourne as a whole, to understand where it breaks down and how design could make these transitions clearer.
Research methods Semi-structured interviews 10–15 minutes In person or online Six participants were recruited through personal networks and interviewed individually. Five were recruited on campus and joined two small group sessions (groups of 2 and 3). The interviews followed each stage of the enrolment journey. I also asked where participants got stuck, who they turned to for help and how they learned the process. 11 students interviewed Academic backgrounds Information Technology Design Science Online questionnaire 3–5 minutes Online via Qualtrics I recruited respondents through personal networks, peer sharing and campus intercepts. The questionnaire asked about the same stages, mostly through multiple-choice and Likert-scale questions, with one open-text question. It also asked about outside help and experiences of the updated enrolment system. 38 valid responses out of 48 Academic backgrounds Law IT Science Design Commerce Arts Environment Data analysis The interview transcripts were analysed using inductive thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006). I labelled short descriptive notes to relevant transcripts, then grouped similar codes into themes. For the questionnaire, I used descriptive statistics, mainly counts and percentages. Then I compared the survey results with the interview themes to identify where similar patterns appeared and where the questionnaire added further detail. 5 themes identified Ethics and consent The fieldwork received ethics approval (ID 32241), and I completed RIOT training before data collection. All participants received the Plain Language Statement and gave consent. Interviewees could skip questions or stop at any time, and all survey questions except consent were optional. The questionnaire was anonymous and interview transcripts were de-identified as P1 to P11. All data were stored on my password-protected computer and will be deleted at the end of the project.
Findings I grouped the interview findings into five themes. Not all respondents answered every question, so the number of responses used for each count or percentage varies by question. Theme 1 Planning and enrolment don’t connect well Eight of the 11 interview participants described adding planned subjects again in the enrolment system. My Course Planner was generally easy to use, but choices made there did not carry into formal enrolment. In the questionnaire, 69% of respondents (25 of 36) had to look up the same information more than once. This reflects the manual checking across tools described by Nguyen et al. (2026) and the NYU Usability Lab (n.d.). 4 of 35 agreed that the University’s systems felt like one connected process “We've already looked at the subject, we've already planned it in our course planner. We just want to select it and add it or select it and remove it.” — P5 37% of respondents selected enrolling in my.unimelb as a difficult part (the most selected option). Theme 2 Enrolling is the most confusing part Interviewees described extra steps, unclear subject statuses and uncertainty about whether enrolment had succeeded. P1 initially believed that adding subjects to the Study Plan meant they were already enrolled. The update also disrupted returning students: 16 of the 25 questionnaire respondents who had used both versions had to work out how to do things again. This confusion is consistent with the enrolment cart misunderstanding reported at MacEwan University (Estevez et al., 2014). “The first time I did it, in my study plan, I thought I enrolled in everything, but I had to tick everything and then enroll again.” — P1 “You have to select it, you have to add it to the main page and then only then can you go and enroll the ones that you've selected.” — P5 80% had to work out parts of the process on their own Theme 3 Students learn the process by figuring it out themselves Interviewees described clicking around, experimenting and asking others how to proceed. Official guidance could tell students which system to use without explaining how to complete the task. Friends, classmates and senior students were the most common outside source of help, selected by 23 of 36 respondents. “I could only follow tutorials from people on RedNote and enrol that way.” — P10 Theme 4 Useful features are easy to miss Some interview participants assumed MyTimetable only showed subjects after enrolling. In the questionnaire, 10 of 34 respondents did not know the Plan tab could be used to check class times before enrolment. The information was available, but students did not always discover it or use it early enough. 5 of 11 interview participants did not know they could check class times before enrolling “I thought that subjects only show up after you enroll in it, to be honest.” — P9 56% changed at least one subject from their original plan Theme 5 Students often need to go back and make changes Earlier choices could be reopened by study-period availability, prerequisites, course requirements or class times. Timetable problems could lead to changing a class or changing a subject. In the questionnaire, 32 of 35 respondents reported at least one timetable problem. “I was planning on doing another subject, but it clashed with my work times. So I was like, maybe I should just do a different subject.” — P3
Design Opportunities 1. Planning and enrolment don’t connect well 2. Enrolling is the most confusing part 3. Students learn the process by figuring it out themselves 4. Useful features are easy to miss 5. Students often need to go back and make changes Carry choices and context forward across stages Make status and next actions visible Provide guidance at the point of need Surface critical information earlier and make revision easier Key findings Carry selected subjects and planning context into the next stage. Reduce repeated searches and manual additions. Distinguish a planned choice from formal enrolment. Show outstanding actions and provide clear confirmation. Explain what to do at the point of action. Keep an accessible guide for students returning to the instructions. Bring relevant class-time constraints into planning. Provide a clear route back when subjects or class times need to change. Design opportunities
Problem Statement How might we help students plan, enrol and build a workable timetable as one connected process, with clear next steps and fewer repeated tasks?
Design Development Low-Fidelity Sketches I began with sketches of the parts of the existing system where students had most problems, focusing on carrying subject choices forward, making enrolment status clearer and checking class times earlier.
Hi-Fi Version 1: Used for Evaluation I used this first high-fidelity prototype to test the redesigned core journey, from subject planning to enrolment. As most of this flow carried into the final design, it is shown here as an overview to avoid repetition. This is the prototype I used for evaluation.
Hi-Fi Version 2: Final Prototype This is my final prototype. Below, I explain how the main features work and why I designed them this way. I have placed it before the evaluation so readers can understand the full journey before reading the test findings. The evaluation in the next section used Hi-Fi Version 1, and participant feedback helped refine this final design. The homepage This is the homepage for subject planning and enrolment. If students need help navigating the page later, they can click the guide button to reopen the help panel. It offers a video tutorial and instructions with screenshots and text, so they can find guidance while staying on the page. The progress bar is the same as the one on the homepage. It also updates when they switch the display view below. Show results gives students a quick look at their marks, so they don’t need to open the separate Results page. Students can switch to Remaining requirements to focus on what they still need to fulfil. The Go to Course Planner link takes them to choose subjects for that requirement. Like the button at the top right of the page, it points them towards their next step. Course Planner After checking their course requirements in My Study, students move to Course Planner to choose their subjects. They can try out multiple combinations by placing subjects in the placeholders and save them as different plans. I collapsed passed semesters by default to give future choices more space. Students can still expand them to look back at their subjects. Students can save subjects if they have not decided when to take them. They can return to Saved subjects later and add them to a semester. I added class times in the Subject Details because I did not want students to find a subject that met all their other needs, but later discover that the times did not work for them. Students can filter subjects by study period, course requirements, level or area of study. Requisites met shows only subjects they meet the entry requirements for. When subjects have a timetable conflict, a warning appears on the course cards and checklist. Students can open it to see the clash. Automatic checks reduce students’ workload and help them spot clashes early, so they do not have to come back to change subjects during timetabling. The compulsory class sessions clash in every available combination. Students can choose whether to look for alternative subjects. Partial conflict means compulsory sessions still fit, but sessions that do not require live attendance may overlap. For example, some lectures have recordings students can watch later. Once students have chosen a replacement subject, they can click the swap button and then they will see this confirmation. The + button lets students start with a blank option or import a semester option from another plan. Choosing the import option from the + button opens this box. Students then select the plan and semester they want to import from. The imported option keeps the source plan’s name, so students can tell where it came from while comparing it with their other options. Decision-making matters most when choosing subjects. The other steps are mainly administrative, so I wanted to give students as much support as possible during the planning stage. This is why I added AI here but not on the other pages. Planning Buddy uses the university Handbook, and with students’ permission, their study information to offer subject suggestions for reference. In this example, the student cannot decide between two subjects, so they ask Planning Buddy for help. After it compares the two subjects, the student asks if there are any similar subjects. Planning Buddy then gives its recommendation. Timetable After deciding which subjects to take in Course Planner, students move on to Timetable to arrange their classes. For a quicker option, students can use Generate timetables. The system will create a list of timetables for them to choose from. The + button beside Breaks opens the time settings. Students can set when they cannot take classes. I added this feature to help students reduce manual filtering. Once applied, the breaks will appear above the timetable. The same unavailable times are also shaded grey on the calendar. Besides showing options that meet their breaks first, students can sort the list by other criteria, such as fewer days on campus or an earlier finish. Enrolment After deciding on a timetable, students will review their subjects, subject categories and tuition fees on the enrolment page. Once students have successfully enrolled, a message will tell them what to do next. A new message will also show up on the homepage to remind students to pay their tuition fees on time. The newly enrolled subjects also appear in My Study, so students can confirm that their enrolment was successful. The degree progress bar helps students see where they currently stand in their overall degree journey. I put a banner here as a reminder, keeping the enrolment status and key dates easy to notice. The description beneath each study tool explains its purpose, so students can distinguish the three tools. In the questionnaire, 28 of 35 participants agreed that they had to work out parts of the process on their own. Interviewees also described learning through trial and error and turning to external platforms for help. Based on this, I built help into the interface so students can get support without leaving the page.  Each tool automatically walks students through a tutorial on their first visit.  The homepage is shown here as an example. The onboarding tutorial The subjects students bring over from Course Planner will appear on the left. My Study Here in My Study, students can see how their course is structured and what requirements they need to meet. It also keeps the official record of the subjects they have passed or enrolled in. The checklist shows the same requirements as the course structure in My Study, with the same option to switch between views. No conflicts means there is at least one workable timetable where the compulsory class sessions do not overlap. These subjects are hidden by default because no workable timetable is available. The label only tells students that there is a clash. It does not stop them from selecting the subject, because they might still discuss timetable arrangements with the university. Only one option is selected at a time. The checklist on the right will update for that option, ensuring students can clearly see how each combination satisfies their course requirements. Alongside creating different plans for their whole degree, students can also explore alternatives within a single plan. They can save different subject combinations as options for the same semester. This is the AI assistant’s entry point in Course Planner. Find Subjects Check Clashes Compare Options Planning Buddy Students can choose classes manually. Hovering over a class time shows a preview on the calendar before they click to select it. All day marks the whole day as unavailable for classes. Students can use Add another time to block several time ranges for the same days. With Add another break, students can add multiple breaks at once. Generated timetables are sorted by whether they meet students’ break requirements. This table also shows their class allocations. Confirming enrolment reserves a place in each of those classes. They can still change their class times before the timetable adjustment deadline. When students return to the homepage, they can see the progress bar reflects the 4 newly enrolled subjects.
Evaluation I conducted in-person usability testing of Hi-Fi Version 1 with 6 participants from the University of Melbourne who had each enrolled in subjects at least 4 times before. Participants completed 4 think-aloud tasks, rated task ease and completion confidence, and shared feedback in a short interview. With their consent, Zoom recorded the screen and their spoken feedback. As the prototype supported a fixed set of interactions, I provided prompts when participants became stuck, so task completion could include facilitator support. Feedback and Iterations Participants wanted to see alternative subjects with partial clashes, as they might not need to attend the class that clashed. One participant also found “No unavoidable clash” unclear. So I added distinct labels to clarify the three clash states. The university already allows timetable planning before enrolment, but my initial research showed that many participants did not know this and usually checked their timetable after enrolling. I placed the entry earlier in Course Planner to make it easier to notice. Hi-Fi Version 1 used a text link because this step was optional, but 3 of 6 participants needed help finding it. Once I confirmed I could design beyond the university’s existing restrictions, I made timetabling a required step before enrolment and replaced the link with a clear button. Hi-Fi Version 1 already moved matching class options to the top after students set their availability. Some participants missed the change, and one wanted to see which option matched best. To make this clearer, I added labels to the final version’s generated timetables. A participant wanted to check subjects’ core, elective or breadth categories at enrolment review. In response, I added a Category column so students can check this before confirming. A participant suggested showing outstanding tuition fees and a payment link, as students might pay the first instalment but forget the second and face a late fee. Participants also wanted clearer next steps after enrolment. I therefore added a message after enrolment and a separate homepage payment reminder.
Limitations Participants were recruited through personal networks, peer sharing and campus intercepts, so the findings may not reflect the experiences of all University of Melbourne students. The evaluation involved only master’s students in IT-related courses and bachelor’s students in design. All had enrolled in subjects several times and had taken part in the earlier research. Their familiarity with the process and the project may have made the prototype easier to understand than it would be for new users. The Figma prototype followed fixed interaction paths. I provided prompts when participants became stuck, so completing a task did not always mean they could complete it independently. Some feedback was given after I explained a feature’s purpose. These comments show participants’ responses once they understood the feature, but do not show whether they could discover and understand it independently. Only Hi-Fi Version 1 was tested. The final design includes changes based on participant feedback, but it has not been tested again. Participants did not complete the same tasks in the existing university systems, and their comparisons with those systems relied on memory. The results therefore cannot show whether this design is easier to use. Its usefulness over a full enrolment period also remains untested.
References Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. , (2), 77–101. Qualitative Research in Psychology3 https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa Cha, S., Loeser, M., & Seo, K. (2024). The impact of AI-based course-recommender system on students’ course-selection decision-making process. , (9), Article 3672.  Applied Sciences14 https://doi.org/10.3390/app14093672 Estevez, R., Rankin, S., Silva, R., & Indratmo. (2014). A model for web-based course registration systems.  International Journal of Web Information Systems10 , (1), 51–64.  https://doi.org/10.1108/IJWIS-05-2013-0014 Ma, B., Lu, M., Taniguchi, Y., & Konomi, S. (2021). Investigating course choice motivations in university environments.  Smart Learning Environments8 , (1), Article 31.  https://doi.org/10.1186/s40561-021-00177-4 Nguyen, D. V., Doroudi, S., & Epstein, D. A. (2026). Community college articulation agreement websites: Students’ suggestions for new academic advising software features. , (5), 396–412.  Community College Journal of Research and Practice50 https://doi.org/10.1080/10668926.2024.2356330 NYU Usability Lab. (n.d.). . NYU Albert – Student course registration https://sites.google.com/nyu.edu/nyuusabilitylab/usability-services/case-studies/nyu-albert-student-course-registration Triyanti, V., Hutahaean, H. A., & Gracia, M. (2025). Usability evaluation of class enrolment application for university students. In  Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Public Administration and Governance, ICOPAG 2024, 30 October 2024, Malang, Indonesia https://doi.org/10.4108/eai.30-10-2024.2354813 . EAI.